Male, Female Or In-Between?

Male, Female Or In-Between?

November 4, 2009, 12:00 am Julietta Jameson marie claire

Runner Caster Semenya made headlines after a gender test discovered she was "intersex". Julietta Jameson talks to people who've received the same disturbing news.

Rating:
(3)
The sun was shining on a glorious spring afternoon when Mani Mitchell sat down in the kitchen of the family's home, in New Zealand's rural south, to ask her mother about the day she was born. Far from a cosy reminiscence, she knew the conversation would be difficult – for years, she had felt an elusive secret hung in the air between them, but discussing anything intimate was just not what her family did. As she joined her mum at the kitchen table, Mani – then in her early 20s – finally managed to pluck up the nerve.

At first, her mother fidgeted and avoided her daughter's eye, before slowly opening up in a low-key, almost dismissive, tone, as if she were discussing the weather. "She said: 'Oh, well, you know, the waters broke early in the morning and Dad got up and drove me to the hospital,'" recalls Mani. "Mum was sent down to the birthing room with a young nurse and apparently I was born about 20 minutes later. The nurse bent down to pick me up and her first words were: 'Oh, my God. It's a hermaphrodite!'"

Dropping this bombshell on her child had a powerful effect on Mani's usually unflappable mother. "She started screaming and ran out of the room," says Mani, now a Wellington psychotherapist. "So I'm left with these two pieces of information; my mother screaming – because I had never seen her show such strong emotion in my life – and this word ‘hermaphrodite'. I didn't know what
it meant and I certainly didn't locate it as meaning anything for me."

She didn't know it then, but Mani had been born "intersex" – the now widely accepted term, replacing the clumsy "hermaphrodite", for people with ambiguous sex physiology, be it internal, external or both. So-called "hermaphrodite" genitals – a fully functioning penis and vagina – are mythical. Mani had ambiguous external genitalia and had undergone "corrective" surgery when she was a baby. Commonly, intersex people like Mani, who are raised as females, have a small, penis-like protrusion where the clitoris is usually found.

Although the condition remains, in Mani's words, shrouded in "silence and secrecy", it's astonishingly prevalent, with some doctors claiming that one per cent of the population can fall into the category, along a spectrum of conditions ranging from misplaced urethras to enlarged clitorises and ambiguous exterior genital physiology. Internal conditions include male or female chromosomes in the opposite sex, hormonal imbalances and male gonads in women. Yet despite its frequency, this "third sex" is poorly understood, and carries "freak show" connotations that make those with it reluctant to speak out.
...

It wasn't until years after the kitchen encounter with her mother, who has since died, that Mani found records of the genital correction surgery she'd undergone as a baby. "I got that piece of information when I was in my early 30s, and it would take another 10 years before I could find the people to work with to make sense of that," she says. Prior to that "there was a lot of running away". Today, though, Mani is comfortable in her own skin. "I don't see myself as exclusively female or male," she says. "But I also know generally how uncomfortable the world is with difference."

Information on intersex
There are many variations of sex organ appearance, hormone levels and other variable sex determinants. If you suspect you or your child are intersex, and it's a concern, you can talk to support groups, in addition to your doctor.

Contact the Australian branch of Organisation Intersex International at http://oiiaustralia.com, or for New Zealand, http://intersex-nz.blogspot.com.

For information about Androgen Insensitivity Syndrome, visit http://home.vicnet.net.au/~aissg/

Read more real-life intersex stories in the December issue of marie claire.

Clarification
In our December 2009 issue, our special report about people with intersex said the term "disorders of sex development" is another term used to describe intersex. Gina Wilson, Australian president of Organisation Intersex International, says her organisation does not support the use of this term.
Show:
Newest First
Oldest First

1 - 10 of 22

First Page | < Previous | Next > | Last Page

22 Comments

  1. we we 08:52pm Monday 09th November 2009 EST Report Abuse

    -** WealthyRomances.com **- If you are single, you can go to our website to find a romantic love belongs to you!Try not be a loss!

  2. Angela 02:02pm Sunday 08th November 2009 EST Report Abuse

    This article contains a number of factual inaccuracies. Read about them at the OII Australia website. Our post about them is titled "Marie Claire Australia December 2009 – Some Notes on Its Article about Intersex".

  3. Joanne 10:10am Saturday 07th November 2009 EST Report Abuse

    BTW - Just to clarify matters, Joanne (myself) is one of the administrators of OII-NZ and a member of the board of OII International. I'm sorry - I should have made that clear at the beginning. :-)

  4. Joanne 09:25am Saturday 07th November 2009 EST Report Abuse

    Caster's Issues are caused by a failure to accept variation in sex formation. Her gender function appears to be healthily that of female, as does her identity. The vast majority of intersex folk identify as either female or male.. Attempts to impose a so-called 'gender identity ...

  5. swallowsnest 09:18am Saturday 07th November 2009 EST Report Abuse

    In sport, just as in the rest of life, we have certain categories. Male, female, junior, veteran, Para Olympian, heavyweight etc and we used to have amateur and professional. If there were enough categories, every unique one of us would become a champion. Viva la difference.

  6. Karen 08:37am Saturday 07th November 2009 EST Report Abuse

    I think you will find that the matter of being born intersex causes gender identity issues. Castor's question of clear gender defintion by accepted terms has caused the problems that she is now living through. Mani's story is similar, as it is for may others throughout the world Her ...

  7. Joanne 08:09am Saturday 07th November 2009 EST Report Abuse

    It's seriously unhelpful to introduce TG gender politics into this.. Intersex is not an identity issue and the so-called 'corrective' surgeries performed on intersex babies cause more problems than they solve. The two things need to be kept separate.

  8. Karen 07:39am Saturday 07th November 2009 EST Report Abuse

    Cont'd; identification is just another area where this happens, despite what many may prefer to think.It has been the case since the beginning of mankind. Even the term hermaphrodite comes from the ancient Greeks. We are a part of the diversity that is the colour of humanity.

  9. Karen 07:37am Saturday 07th November 2009 EST Report Abuse

    Cont'd; identification is just another area where this happens, despite what many may prefer to think.It has been the case since the beginning of mankind. Even the term hermaphrodite comes from the ancient Greeks. We are a part of the diversity that is the colour of humanity.

  10. Sol T 07:31am Saturday 07th November 2009 EST Report Abuse

    Just leave her alone. Theres nothing wrong. People who think there is something wrong with her are just shallow and superficial! Let her live her glory, she won the race fair and square

1 - 10 of 22

First Page | < Previous | Next > | Last Page

Post your comment

Comment Guidelines
Do you have a Yahoo! ID? Sign in | Sign up

You Tell Us

Do you wear sunscreen every day?

Do you wear sunscreen every day?

Vote View results without voting