Our Experts

The Art of Intimacy

Changing a Child's Gender With Hormones

Would you allow your child to choose to be a man or a woman?

A hospital in Boston might be doing just that. Doctors at the Children's Hospital in Boston are performing hormone-blocking treatments on young boys and girls who are struggling with gender identity. These hormone treatments block the onslaught of puberty, allowing the children to reach maturity before deciding whether or not they want to undergo a sex change. These treatments do not actually constitute a sex change, rather they give patients more time to decide whether or not they want to transition to the opposite sex.

However, the idea that children of 8 or 9 years old do not already have a definite gender identity might be flawed. Research shows that children have firmly set gender identity by as early as age 3, so in fact, these adolescents probably already know whether or not they feel "trapped" in the wrong gender's body. Furthermore, there has not been a tremendous amount of research on the long-term effects of hormone treatments on children, and these decisions could potentially affect everything from a child's future fertility to their physical health.

The good news about these treatments is that more people are beginning to understand that gender identity is fluid. Despite our society's rigid definitions of gender, the truth is that gender is flexible and transient. Treatments such as these help society embrace sexual freedom and self-expression. Even so, it might behoove us to wait before treating children with potentially life-changing hormones.

After all, if this country makes adolescents wait until they are 18 years old to vote, shouldn't we also have them wait until they are 18 to make significant decisions about their bodies?

------------------------------------------------------------

Get Dr. Laura Berman's customized advice for you:
Free Assessment

110 Comments Report Abuse
1. stevevientiane - May 29 12:43pm
Any irreversible cosmetic surgery on an otherwise healthy body should be delayed until a person is old enough to make an informed decision.
2. stevevientiane - May 29 12:44pm
Any irreversible cosmetic surgery on an otherwise healthy body should be delayed until a person is old enough to make an informed decision.
3. janet_havel - May 29 12:50pm
children make these decisions even if we don't want them too. they drink, smoke, have sex, get pierced and tattooed before turning 18. legally they aren't allowed to, but you can't really stop a child from doing these kinds of things. the best we can do is educate and provide for them
4. kanishawilliams17 - May 29 04:08pm
i really think that is sick if god wonted it that way thats how he would have mad it
5. avani16 - May 29 04:49pm
I really hope that nobody considers changing the gender of their children based on this doctors article or any other doctor for that matter. Dr. Berman or whoever thinks this way is what I call HALF-BAKED and somebody who is CUCKOO-IN-THE-HEAD!!!
6. isabelle_raulin_daymeries - May 29 06:41pm
Dear dr. Laura,

I don't know whether postponing puberty is the right solution. But it's certainly a good thing to post the question. I'm 47, and have been out as a tranny for 6 years. I've also been in full psychoanalysis for those 6 years, and one thing I do know is that nobody has the education or experience to decide on an issue like this at 14, and even at 18, without a substantial effort on personal development. So at least the treatment gives those kids the time to work on themselves. They may have a fixed gender identity at 3, but that certainly doesn't mean they are ready for transition at 12 or 14. Frankly, I don't see too many happy tansitioned folks around.

Again, thank you for posting this,

Isabelle
7. isabelle_raulin_daymeries - May 29 06:45pm
Dear dr. Laura,

I don't know whether postponing puberty is the right solution. But it's certainly a good thing to post the question. I'm 47, and have been out as a tranny for 6 years. I've also been in full psychoanalysis for those 6 years, and one thing I do know is that nobody has the education or experience to decide on an issue like this at 14, and even at 18, without a substantial effort on personal development. So at least the treatment gives those kids the time to work on themselves. They may have a fixed gender identity at 3, but that certainly doesn't mean they are ready for transition at 12 or 14. Frankly, I don't see too many happy tansitioned folks around.

Again, thank you for posting this,

Isabelle
8. bowwow13m - May 29 07:14pm
You guys are sickos!
God created man how he wanted to and now you people want to change all of that?!?
Disgusting.
9. alnilamh - May 29 08:48pm
Ridiculous tripe! Children's Hospital in Boston, if they are really doing this, is right up there with Nazi Germany's "medical experimentation" on captive Jews. What parents would allow such monstrous interference with the normal development of their child??!

Boston, keep your hormones out of our nation's children!!
10. peggymartin007 - May 29 09:41pm
I absolutely agree; Children should not undergo hormone treatments to prevent puberty. If, as an adult, they choose to change their gender, it is their choice. I do not believe children under the age of 16 have the maturity to make a life decision like this.
Leave your comments You must sign in to leave a comment
Sponsored Links

YAHOO!XTRA LIFESTYLE:

ALSO ON YAHOO!XTRA: